The landmark monopoly trial between the U.S. Justice Department and Google comes to a finale this week. After a five-month hiatus, both sides will present closing arguments starting Thursday aiming to persuade the federal judge why they should win the case.
The Justice Department has accused Google of illegally abusing its power as a monopoly to control the search engine business — leading to competitors being sidelined and customers being shortchanged by getting a lower quality experience. Google, for its part, has argued its search engine is simply the best, that’s why it’s the most popular — not because of its business dealings.
It’s the first high-profile monopoly case to go to trial among a handful that the U.S. government has brought against tech companies in recent years. The U.S. has also sued Amazon, Apple and Facebook parent Meta over business practices it says hurts both rivals and consumers.
Google paid $26.3 billion in 2021 alone to be the default search engine on phones and web browsers
The Justice Department’s case hinged on allegations that Google illegally orchestrated its business dealings with device makers, like Apple and Samsung, and web browser companies, like Mozilla, which runs Firefox.
During the trial, the government showed that Google paid billions of dollars every year for exclusive agreements with these companies. In 2021, it spent a total of $26.3 billion to ensure it was the default search engine on phones and web browsers, according to witness testimony. Apple, which had the most lucrative deal, was paid around $18 billion in 2021, according to the New York Times.
“Google illegally maintained a monopoly for more than a decade,” Kenneth Dintzer, the Justice Department’s lead lawyer, said in the trial’s opening statements. “If Google sets the rules, it will always be to their advantage.”
Google’s parent company Alphabet, which is now worth more than $2 trillion, controls roughly 90% of the U.S. search engine market. For its defense, the company put together a massive legal team and brought on outside law firms to help fight its case.
Even Microsoft CEO says it couldn’t compete with Google
Over the course of the trial, the Justice Department called dozens of witnesses to testify – including experts, psychologists and top executives from Apple, Microsoft and Google.
When Microsoft CEO Nadella took the stand, he said that he tried for years to get Apple to set Microsoft’s Bing search engine as the default on iPhones and iPads. He added, however, that even a company as big as Microsoft couldn’t compete.
[the_ad id=’12166′]